Thiil: Positive (-), Good experience and presence, foreign languages, android user.
Zandor: Positive (-): Realistic, good answer to what is a GS
Dobby: Neutral (-): Immortalis only, only guild running experience.
xNinjaDecode: Neutral (+) [positive if need for Immortalis GS]: Good answers, very active, immortalis only.
Saphiregirlgem [Diamondgem]: Positive (+): Very active, 2 games covered, organised events on forum.
Bomackin: Positive (-): very active and knowledgeable on MP but his answers to some questions are weak
Roreddy: Positive (-): Very active top player in MP, reasonable answers, I am seriously concerned about conflict of interest once GS though.
GearsOfFate: Positive if looking for Pirate maiden GS, Neutral otherwise.
Pollock: Negative: active MP & Immortalis player, good answers however, experience in game showed Pollock on the beggar side of players asking guildies for monsters all the time but not offering much in return (he eventually got kicked from guild for that reason).
Kain123: Neutral (-): unconvincing answers
Kaito: Negative: unconvincing answers, terrible level of written English in application shows lack of seriousness.
Shotz: Neutral: too new player but to be considered seriously on next batch of recruitment.
Prismsbro: Negative: would not trust a 12years old for GS even though he has quite good answers.
Gannon: Positive: Never came across him in game but very convincing answers and good profile, might be same style as me: monitor things, let the community lead a happy life and step in only if necessary.
Based on that my favourites are (in order):
Diamondgem, Gannon, Bomackin.