If you are S.S Zelbess, then you are actually 7 levels above me which is why I gained so many brawl points from you. Also, I usually defeated you 4-1 or 5-0 which gave me even more. And you get a bonus amount of brawl points just from attacking someone from the guild event. Hope that helps.
Actually it does. Got 1356BP for brawling top ranked at the time, 4-1 victory but cost me 145 so not very efficient. Still, helps answer what I've been doing wrong. I always went for 3 wins in the past to save on cost but it looks like efficiently
going for 5 in each brawl is the way to go.
I do wonder why changing my defense to all pixies reportedly didn't make a difference in the BP opponents earned. I would think that this would force them to use weaker cards to beat me, or they would overspend on big cards - either case resulting in lower BP unless it automatically rewarded using high level cards no matter what they were beating, but from my testing it doesn't seem to do that.
Perhaps it strictly counts just # of wins and then adds the relevant bonuses to determine final BP since if it rewarded "quality" of wins my all-pixie team would be weak on rewards.