Oi shouldn't have clicked this...
Visuals were a solid 10/10.
Acting from Fassbender was a solid 10/10.
Lindelof's script was a huge mess. Characters were poorly written. Conflicts were introduced and dismissed in record time. At no point in the film did characters react to situations realistically, appropriately, or maturely.
The score was uneven and threw off the tone of the film. Go back and watch Alien or Alien 3. Those scores were absolutely perfect for this style of film. It sets the mood of the film without getting in its way. It was haunting and beautiful, in a disturbing and eerie way. Prometheus's score was bloated, obnoxious, and inappropriate.
And most offensive at all, it wasn't scary. There were a few jump scares, but no lasting tension or suspense.
My final score was 6/10.
My review on IMDB