look i dont want to ruin this thread over something so petty. Okaton said it pretty well, use whatever you enjoy and what works for the you. the GvG set has many advantages over the PvP set and vise versa. I actually sat down and thought about this decision for a long time (i didnt know about the alch set back then), and chose pvp simply based on the slow proc, increased block rate (as i only use 1-handed weps) and the fact that Desu had such great success with it. Also i rely a lot more on my block rate and dmg reduc than i do on my defense. Its obviously not a perfect set but honestly none of them are. Nidoo performs amazingly considering what she uses is considered to be the worst set (legacy) for a 70 temp by many people, yet somehow it works for her really well combined with the sleep hammer and crit rate shield, and allows her to move around and cap extremely well .