I voted a 1 (Hey, you guys are on a streak!)
Still infested with hackers. The team has successfully taken down all the nice free things non-cashers could enjoy; gold loot forge, burning on weekends, and loot box. We're given vague notions about things 'being fixed.' It takes months for the first two and I won't hold my breath on the last. The events have been okay. I almost spend no ap at all on this game thanks to more AP price increases and the remodeling of how the jackpot/lucky boxes work. Only thing I bought were boxes, now that's a joke. You have successfully completely killed the last remnant of a shred of joy I had for this game. Bravo.
2. Starlight Story
Cash grab tactics. Developers seem incredibly lazy/inadequate with how slow it takes to get basic things functioning as they should. Level cap of 70, highest zone level is 55. Highest level dungeons: 60. Game had potential, but another complete and utter failure. More development before you release? I think it might hold the record for 'shortest duration of open beta'.
3. Scarlet Blade
I uninstalled after alpha, and every time I think I want to play it again, I visit the forums to see all the people complaining about...Cash grab tactics. High costs, low payouts, and imbalance issues. These are general Aeria problems that Aeria doesn't seem to care about. There are better f2p models out there, but it seems you're only interested in the 'quick cash now, lose players at a high rate til the game dies' scheme.
4. Born to Fire
Do you even remember you still have this game? Another game that had potential, but is wrecked in eternal beta.
The only thing you have going for you is that you have good people working for you. Well, at least half. I've seen great GM communication in SLS and WT (only very recently for WT). Although I worry about the random bans floating around. Hackers? Sure you can have your account back in one day! Oh, you used ***s to insinuate use of a curse word? 3d/perm ban. Yeah, that makes sense.
Did anyone read the MPAA ratings Superman linked when he said forums were PG-13? I don't think the newer GMs have. Yeah, you don't need an excuse to ban, but banning people over silly things that don't actually technically break the rules and letting blatant violations go only disenfranchises the community even more every day.
I'm only still here because my gf still loves Wolfteam. I try new games in the hope that you're trying something new, but over the years you've shown me that the only way you change is for the worse AGE. I actually expect absolutely nothing from you. I only mourn when you acquire more semi-decent games to ruin.
But hey, it's really not just you. A lot of the major f2p publishers still in business use the same crappy p2w models. Then you have a few companies who are 'LoL'ing all the way to the bank.